Jeremiah's Picks · In Jeremiah's words
Eagles
Hotel California
1976 · Asylum Records
- Produced by
- Bill Szymczyk
- Genre
- Rock
- Tracks
- 9
- Runtime
- About 43 minutes
Standout tracks
- Hotel California
- New Kid in Town
- Life in the Fast Lane
- The Last Resort
I need to establish something before proceeding.
I do not dislike the Eagles.
I dislike the assumption that every song recorded in California during the 1970s is automatically a masterpiece.
Tony has difficulty understanding the distinction.
He considers Hotel California essential listening. I consider it an excellent record that has been subjected to approximately fifty years of excessive admiration.
Those are not mutually exclusive positions.
The title track is undeniably impressive. Don Felder and Joe Walsh deliver one of rock's great guitar finales, and the song manages to be mysterious without becoming incomprehensible.
People have spent decades arguing about what the hotel represents.
I have my own theories.
Tony has his.
Neither of us has convinced the other.
"Life in the Fast Lane" is the album's real muscle. Joe Walsh's guitar riff gives it an edge that keeps the band's famously polished sound from becoming too comfortable.
"New Kid in Town" is another story. It's beautifully constructed, perfectly sung, and precisely the kind of song that makes Tony look pleased with himself whenever he plays it.
I find that irritating.
Not the song.
His expression.
The album closes with "The Last Resort," which I think deserves more attention. Beneath its gentle surface is a pointed meditation on development, environmental destruction, and the human habit of ruining the places we claim to love.
It's a much sharper song than casual listeners might expect.
A customer once asked me whether I thought the Eagles were overrated.
I said that being overrated and being excellent were not mutually exclusive.
He seemed disappointed.
People apparently prefer simpler answers.
Here's mine: Hotel California is a very good album. Occasionally a great one. Its musicianship is first-rate, its production is meticulous, and its best songs have earned their place in rock history.
I still reserve the right to roll my eyes when Tony puts it on for the third time in a week.
That's not criticism.
That's workplace survival.
— Jeremiah
Got a record Jeremiah should hear?
He'll listen. He won't promise to like it.